The Case for Writing Multiple Songs at Once

When I first started writing songs, I wrote one song at a time until it was finished. This process was so delicate for me that I convinced myself that I had to write the entire song in one sitting or it would be forgotten forever. As a result, my writing sessions were sporadic bursts, going on for hours and hours, then never picking up the pen again for weeks.

This worked well for me when I was in high school and bored on summer vacation. It even worked in college because I had to write songs for assignments. Unfortunately, after graduating, this songwriting process led me to many dry months and I ended up writing just two or three songs for an entire year. That continued for the first few years after starting to work full-time.

Last year, I wrote thirty-one songs.

This year, I’ve already written twenty songs, and it’s only April.

Fact of the matter is, I don’t have the time to hammer out a song in one day. Even if I did have time, I simply don’t have the energy. The more you learn about the craft, the more difficult songwriting can become (which is why so many people don’t believe in learning songwriting). But if I don’t continue learning, I don’t grow as a writer and I don’t feel very inspired. It is hard to crank out a great song all in one day, though that still happens sometimes.

I stumbled into my solution by accident: I started writing multiple songs at once.

Although this was also because I started co-writing, writing even two songs at once gave me a sense of freedom. I could focus on just one or two sections of a song and come back the next day and write more. Nothing had to be perfect. The pressure was off.

Here is what writing multiple songs at once looks like for me:

1. Sitting down to write for thirty minutes to an hour a day, max.

2. Opening up my notebook or song folder and just playing through old songs, practicing and seeing if little edits are needed.

3. Playing one half-finished song and seeing if I can think of another verse, or if the melody needs improving, etc.

4. Hitting a roadblock in one half-finished song, so I open another and play around. Maybe I open another song. Sometimes I hit inspiration at this point and just finish the whole song.

5. Sometimes I do a songwriting exercise. Sometimes I just play around on my instrument and enjoy myself.

Although writing multiple songs at once might look different for you, I believe the benefits will be very similar. The most beneficial part of this was definitely the change in mindset. If nothing worked out today, at least I tried to write, and I could come back tomorrow. 

This might not be a goal for you, but writing more songs felt great. I feel I have an easier time sorting what I do write into the release pile, the pitch pile, etc. Sometimes the pleasure of songwriting comes not in the duration, but having written.

Sometimes the pleasure of songwriting comes not in the duration, but having written.

Not only do I feel I’ve expressed myself more, there is less pressure on the music I do write. I don’t have to release every single song I’ve written. I might write a song and think, “No one else is ever going to hear this, but that’s okay. I still love this song, just for me.”

Another bonus: usually I stumble upon a new song idea because I’ve made the space for songwriting. It might be a lyrical idea, a riff, an interesting chord progression—I write it down, record it in an iPhone memo, etc. By showing up, I have invited in these new ideas.

My goal is not to write so mechanically that the process becomes stressful. Perhaps this doesn’t work for commissioned work or work-for-hires, but I have really begun to enjoy a songwriting process that isn’t always so inviting. If that’s your goal, give this a try—it might surprise you!