Is a piece of art ever truly finished? For me, there’s always something I could have changed, another line that isn’t quite there. There are so many aspects to songwriting that tempt me to add one more neat little internal rhyme, or tweak the melody to create more motion, or even re-think all my metaphors.
But when I’m on the fifth iteration of a song, I know that I’m probably overdoing it. At this point, I give myself a basic set of guidelines that help me determine if the song is communicating effectively enough to call it done, and move onto the other fun parts. Like production!
Check the plotline
For most songs, we’re trying to tell the story, even if it’s a particularly short one. Does the Verse feel like it presents a conflict, and the Chorus has some sort of resolution or explanation of that conflict? Does the story build as the song goes along to Verse 2 and the Bridge? Does the song have a climax?
Check the melodies
Are your melodies too similar from section to section? Does the Chorus stand out? It doesn’t have to be catchy, but if that’s what you want, do you find it an easy melody to remember and get stuck in your head?
Check the rhymes
Do all your rhymes actually rhyme, or can you tighten them up? Do you follow your rhyme schemes properly?
Check the details
Say all your lines out loud: do they all make sense? Are they in the same tone (conversational or poetic)? Are they in the right tense? Are there any random details in the song that don’t really need to be there, that don’t actually relate to the sentiment in the Chorus?
Check your drafts
If all else fails, sometimes it really is about how many drafts you’ve done. The guideline might be different for you, but I try to stop re-writing sections at around draft three and stop small tweaks at draft five.
Even if your song isn’t quite there…
If there’s something bothering you and you’re not quite sure what it is, take a break from it. I often find that in a couple of weeks, either:
a) I figure out what was bothering me and make the changes.
b) Nothing was actually wrong in the first place!
If enough time has passed, it’s okay to just call it done and move forward. No song is perfect, and it still deserves to be out there even if there are things you would look back on and change. That’s also how we know we’re growing and learning as songwriters.
Call it done, and write the next song. 🙂